• Our Networks
  • Energy Council
  • Climate Council
  • Minerals and Royalties Council
Energy Council
  • How It Works
    • Our Story
    • Executive Team
    • Membership
    • Minerals & Royalties Council
    • Women’s Council
      • The Global Female Influencer 275
    • Success Stories
  • Resources
    • Market Intelligence & Interviews
    • Webinars
    • Podcasts
    • On-Demand Video
  • Events
  • Partner
    • Why Partner
  • Investor Access
  • Contact Us
Select Page

Thought Leader

The State of the Minerals & Royalties Market in Oklahoma

by Robert Hefner, President & CEO, Hefner Energy

10 December 2020

Robert Hefner, President & CEO, Hefner Energy shares a Year in Review looking at the state of the Minerals & Royalties market in Oklahoma.  This article was originally published by Hefner Energy here.

A Year in Review

As told by the chart below, which plots the count of deeds and total dollars spent by month in Oklahoma, Oklahoma’s mineral and royalty market is at its worst point since the shale revolution began circa 2008. Moreover, it’s impossible to ignore the dramatic rise of private equity in the mineral and royalty space from 2016-2019, when over $1 billion was being spent per annum.

The Big Players since 2000

When filtering the data to companies that spent at least $10 million, there are only 82 companies on the list since 2000. 

The top 3 are:

  1. Longpoint Minerals – $413.6 million
  2. Mineral Resources Company (i.e. Continental Resources): $393.5 million

  3. Echo Minerals: $320.5 million

The third-place firm on this list will likely surprise many because they haven’t been nearly as active as the other two in recent years. Regardless, they still must hold a considerable inventory that’s cash flowing quite nicely by now. Their inclusion in the top three begs the question, who’s left standing?

Who’s Left Standing?

When you filter down further to which ones have spent just $2 million YTD, that list of 86 shrinks down to just 4 firms, of which two are publicly-traded (being CLR and MNRL). In fact, if you were to spend just $5 million dollars this year buying minerals and royalties in Oklahoma you’d be the 3rd largest buyer of minerals in the whole state! Oh how the mighty have fallen.

“We Buy PDP” Move Buyers Back to the ‘Core’?

2008-2014:
During this period, Oklahoma’s shales were still largely unknown and untested. As you might suspect, the percentage of dollars spent in each play were distributed somewhat evenly. During this period, only about 1/5th of the dollars spent were in what would become known as the SCOOP and the STACK.

2015-Q2.2016
During this period, the STACK was firming itself up to be the next hot play. The whole play was put squarely on the map in December 2015 when Devon Energy announced they were acquiring Felix Energy in a blockbuster $2.5 billion deal valuing leasehold in the $20,000 per acre ballpark. As one would suspect, the percentage of dollars allocated towards the STACK during this period was significant and it was. Unfortunately, the STACK fell out of favor once the Meramec was properly tested – initially with the Showboat and Mosasaurus units in 16N-09W, Kingfisher County. Investors were burned and they really haven’t come back since.

Q3.2016-2019
This period begins June 2018, upon the blockbuster announcement by Continental Resources of its famed Project Springboard in the SCOOP. This was, and still is, the most aggressive density development the state has ever known. Continental announced they would drill 350 horizontal wells in a 9×9 mile contiguous area in central Grady County between three zones – the Springer, Sycamore, and Woodford – and the dollars flocked that way.

COVID- 2 0
To say this year has been challenging would be an understatement. It has sent rigs falling from more than 100 to single-digits (another record low I’m sure). It has sent firms to the graveyard, and very few mineral buyers are left standing. Of those still standing, they largely are equity players who managed to avoid leverage and they are now unanimously only paying for PDP (and trying to pay PV 15-25 at that).

I would have imagined the percentage of dollars would have sent acquisitions straight to the “core only” areas in only the SCOOP and STACK. Instead, about 1/4th of the market is paying for acreage in the non-SCOOP/STACK areas that are both undelineated and statistically challenging. I would have imagined that debt loads and PDP buyers would have been forced back to the cores of just the SCOOP and STACK where those challenges are mitigated.

Dollars Paid Per Acre Have Eroded

In addition to the volume of market transactions falling off the proverbial cliff, so have average prices paid per acre.

It is important to note:

  • these values are NOT normalized to 1/8th royalty or any other. In Oklahoma, the average royalty rate is 18.75% so, if you want to think in terms of price per NRA, you can normalize these prices downwards if anything.

  • The chart shows average price paid per acre across the entire state – the prices in core areas look vastly different, and our systems have been built to provide incredible, real-time transparency on every single transaction that occurs in the state.

The small “bump” in our data for November 2020 is encouraging. However, those who are waiting for pre-covid prices will undoubtedly be holding their breath for a very long time.

Thankful and Open for Business

I am fortunate for the transactional business this year, and quite thankful to all those involved. Without it, my life would look drastically different. Being able to transact this year has re-instilled a bit of lost confidence both in myself and the advanced analytics systems Hefner Energy spent five years developing for a market that seems so out of favor today.

These successes wouldn’t be possible without the broad shoulders of others, either. I’m thankful to my former partner, Justin Woody, an engineer who directly managed the Pinedale field taught me rock mechanics. As a result of his experience with downspacing to 2.5 acres, we avoided underwriting any more than 8 wells in any unit in the STACK when others were risking 14, or more.

The famous quote that luck is “preparation meeting opportunity” seems to fit this year. While the transaction we just closed might only result in a fraction of the revenue Hefner Energy has become accustomed to over the past few years, it also might be the only successful closing of a sizable mineral and royalty transaction in the market this year. We must celebrate the wins.

We are thankful to continue to be open for business. Oklahoma is down, but it’s not out.

  • We are actively acquiring minerals across the lower 48,

  • We offer minerals management services (you benefit from someone who manages their own portfolio), and

  • We offer exclusive advisory services, predicated upon our advanced data and analytics systems.

It has been a wonderful end to a very challenging year, and it’s not lost on me that most have not fared as well. We hope to be able to help others who could use a boost as well. If you think I can help you, I’m just a phone call or email away. Nothing is more satisfying than helping others. Cya 2020, and Godspeed to 2021.

More about Hefner Energy

Hefner Energy is passionate about energy, climate, minerals & royalties and fighting for those less fortunate. We are energy experts, providing original insights and solutions to the most complex of problems. Visit the Hefner Energy website here.

Listen to The Minerals & Royalties Podcast Ep 19 with Robert Hefner here

  • All
  • Minerals & Royalties Podcasts
  • Minerals & Royalties Webinar
Podcast: Yoann Hispa & Craig Kaiser, Co-Founders of LandGate

Podcast: Yoann Hispa & Craig Kaiser, Co-Founders of LandGate

Yoann Hispa & Craig Kaiser, Co-founders of LandGate join the Minerals & Royalties Podcast. Yoann and Craig tell us more about the ...

Podcast: Troy Tittlemier, CEO, MagmaChem Research Institute

Podcast: Troy Tittlemier, CEO, MagmaChem Research Institute

Troy Tittlemier, CEO, MagmaChem Research Institute joins the Minerals & Royalties Podcast. Troy tell us more about why he thinks ...

Family Office Investment Strategies in Minerals & Royalties

Family Office Investment Strategies in Minerals & Royalties

As part of the Minerals & Royalties webinar series we will be debating family office investment strategies. Register here to join the ...

On Demand: Is there a place for private equity in the minerals & royalties space?

On Demand: Is there a place for private equity in the minerals & royalties space?

Is there a place for private equity in the minerals & royalties space? Many pundits in the industry don’t think there is. Watch our ...

Podcast: Collin Lensing, COO & General Counsel, Vendera Resources

Podcast: Collin Lensing, COO & General Counsel, Vendera Resources

On this episode of the Royalties & Minerals Podcast, we hear from Collin Lensing, COO & General Counsel, Vendera Resources . Listen here

On-Demand: Buyside Strategies in the Minerals & Royalties Space Amidst COVID-19 and the Oil price War

On-Demand: Buyside Strategies in the Minerals & Royalties Space Amidst COVID-19 and the Oil price War

Everyone in the minerals & royalties space is looking to get a large institution to acquire their portfolio but with COVID-19 and the ...

Podcast: Arrowhead Energy Partners

Podcast: Arrowhead Energy Partners

Travis Low, Matt Ritter, and Jim Shuss join us from Arrowhead Energy Partners to chat about the Arrowhead story and why they decided to

Podcast: Diversification vs Specialization – Minerals & Royalties

Podcast: Diversification vs Specialization – Minerals & Royalties

On October 13th, 2020 a group of leading minerals & royalties Executives gathered to debate the pros & cons of building minerals & ...

Podcast: Jimmy Murchison – CEO, Hatch Resources

Podcast: Jimmy Murchison – CEO, Hatch Resources

Jimmy Murchison – CEO, Hatch Resources joins the OGC Podcast to discuss the role of debt financing and hedging in the minerals space . ...

On-Demand: What it Takes to Exit a Minerals & Royalties Portfolio

On-Demand: What it Takes to Exit a Minerals & Royalties Portfolio

As more and more capital has entered into the minerals & royalties space over the past 5-6 years, there has been a growing debate ...

Podcast: Matt Sands, Managing Member of Silverheels Investments and Host of The Mineral Rights PodCast

Podcast: Matt Sands, Managing Member of Silverheels Investments and Host of The Mineral Rights PodCast

Matt Sands, Managing Member of Silverheels Investments and Host of The Mineral Rights PodCast joins the Minerals & Royalties Podcast to

Podcast: Josh Adler, CEO, Sourcewater

Podcast: Josh Adler, CEO, Sourcewater

Josh Adler, CEO, Sourcewater joins the Minerals & Royalties Podcast to discuss how they are predicting development activity in the ...

Podcast: Ryan Childs & Abhishek Kumar, Principals of Production Lending LLC

Podcast: Ryan Childs & Abhishek Kumar, Principals of Production Lending LLC

Ryan Childs & Abhishek Kumar, Principals of Production Lending LLC join us to discuss some of the preferred equity and debt solutions ...

Podcast: Minerals & Royalties Aggregation Strategies Panel Discussion

Podcast: Minerals & Royalties Aggregation Strategies Panel Discussion

On this episode of the Royalties & Minerals Podcast, we hear from our panel of experts on Minerals & Royalties Aggregation Strategies. ...

On-Demand: Minerals & Royalties Portfolio Strategies: Diversification vs Specialization

On-Demand: Minerals & Royalties Portfolio Strategies: Diversification vs Specialization

After COVID-19 and the Oil Price War disrupted US Shale, many are now seeing advocating the benefits of building a diversified strategy

Podcast: Mackie Cannon, CEO, OneMap Mineral Services

Podcast: Mackie Cannon, CEO, OneMap Mineral Services

On this episode of the Royalties & Minerals Podcast, Mackie talks about OneMap’s patient capital enabling them to take a longer-term ...

Podcast: Scott Noble, CEO, Noble Royalties

Podcast: Scott Noble, CEO, Noble Royalties

On this episode of the Royalties & Minerals Podcast, Scott breaks down the dynamics in today’s current market and explains how Noble ...

Podcast: Armand Paradis & Jeremy Gottlieb, Co-Founders, Inside Petroleum

Podcast: Armand Paradis & Jeremy Gottlieb, Co-Founders, Inside Petroleum

On this episode of the Royalties & Minerals Podcast Armand Paradis & Jeremy Gottlieb, Co-Founders, Inside Petroleum discuss their ...

On-Demand: Minerals & Royalties Aggregation Strategies

On-Demand: Minerals & Royalties Aggregation Strategies

How do the ground game dynamics differ from basin to basin in today’s market? Is the bid-ask-spread the same on the ground vs ...

Podcast: Ahna Mee & Jackie Haney, Co-Founders and Managing Partners, UnionRock Partners

Podcast: Ahna Mee & Jackie Haney, Co-Founders and Managing Partners, UnionRock Partners

On this episode of the Royalties & Minerals Podcast, Jackie Haney and Ahna Mee join us from UnionRock Partners to talk about the ...

Podcast: Preston Page – Managing Member, Everest Energy

Podcast: Preston Page – Managing Member, Everest Energy

On this episode of the Royalties & Minerals Podcast, Preston Page talks about his team’s data driven approach has led them to be more ...

Brandon O'Gara – Chief Financial Officer, Echo Energy

Brandon O'Gara – Chief Financial Officer, Echo Energy

On this episode of the Royalties & Minerals Podcast Brandon O’Gara talks about how Echo has leverage an “in-house approach” to scale up

Daniel Herz – President & CEO, Falcon Minerals Corporation

Daniel Herz – President & CEO, Falcon Minerals Corporation

On this episode of the Royalties & Minerals Podcast Daniel Herz explains the similarities between the minerals & royalties space and of

Oscar Torres – CEO, Tower Rock Oil & Gas

Oscar Torres – CEO, Tower Rock Oil & Gas

On this episode of the Royalties & Minerals Podcast Oscar Torres talks about his teams value driven approach to acquisitions and how ...

Robert Hefner, President & CEO, Hefner Energy

Robert Hefner, President & CEO, Hefner Energy

On this episode of the Royalties & Minerals Podcast Robert Hefner talks about the Anadarko Basin, stochastic and deterministic modeling

Podcast – Josh Camp, President & CEO, Perpetual Production

Podcast – Josh Camp, President & CEO, Perpetual Production

Josh Camp shares his insights in this podcast. During the episode, Josh discusses the various ways his team approaches mineral buying ...

Podcast – Chris Beato, CEO & Co-Founder, Rocking WW Minerals

Podcast – Chris Beato, CEO & Co-Founder, Rocking WW Minerals

Chris Beato shares his insights in this podcast. During the episode, Chris leverages his 35+ years experience in the industry to ...

Podcast – Jace Graham, President, Rising Phoenix Resources

Podcast – Jace Graham, President, Rising Phoenix Resources

Jace Graham shares his insights in this podcast. During the episode, Jace talks about his team’s approach to the ground game and how ...

Podcast – KC Stallings, President, Desert Royalty Company

Podcast – KC Stallings, President, Desert Royalty Company

KC Stalling shares his insights in this podcast. During the episode, KC talks about the ups & downs of investing in the minerals space ...

Podcast – Matt Wieszczyk, Managing Member, Par City Holdings

Podcast – Matt Wieszczyk, Managing Member, Par City Holdings

Matt Wieszczy shares his insights in this podcast. During the episode, Matt explains some of the advantages that smaller aggregators ...

Podcast – Nick Varel, President & CEO, Wing Resources

Podcast – Nick Varel, President & CEO, Wing Resources

Nick Varel shares his insights in this podcast. During the episode, Nick talks about the resiliency of the North American oil business ...

Podcast – Josh Lorenz, President, EnCore Permian

Podcast – Josh Lorenz, President, EnCore Permian

Josh Lorenz shares his insights in this podcast. During the episode, Josh explains why now is a great time for family offices and high ...

Podcast – Cutler Gist, Principal, Montego Minerals

Podcast – Cutler Gist, Principal, Montego Minerals

Cutler Gist shares his insights in this podcast. During our conversation, Cutler explains the fundamentals of using a 1031 Exchange and

Podcast – Adam Waterous, CEO, Waterous Energy Fund

Podcast – Adam Waterous, CEO, Waterous Energy Fund

Adam Waterous shares his insights in this podcast. Adam discusses his theory of “Peak Permian”, which describes current US production ...

Podcast – Derren Geiger, CEO & Portfolio Manager, Cornerstone Acquisition & Management Company

Podcast – Derren Geiger, CEO & Portfolio Manager, Cornerstone Acquisition & Management Company

Derren Geiger shares his insights in this podcast. Derren discusses how Cornerstone’s strategy is driven by the macro and geopolitical ...

Podcast – Chris Bentley, President & CEO, Bellatorum Resources

Podcast – Chris Bentley, President & CEO, Bellatorum Resources

Chris Bentley, President & CEO, Bellatorum Resources shares his insights in this podcast. Chris discusses Bellatorum’s “velocity of ...

Podcast – Paden McKinney & Griffin Haby III, Co-Founders, Mountain Lion Oil & Gas

Podcast – Paden McKinney & Griffin Haby III, Co-Founders, Mountain Lion Oil & Gas

Paden McKinney & Griffin Haby III, Co-Founders, Mountain Lion Oil & Gas share their insights in this podcast. Griffin & Paden discuss ...

Podcast – Charlie Matter, CEO, CASE Energy Partners

Podcast – Charlie Matter, CEO, CASE Energy Partners

Charlie Matter, CEO, CASE Energy Partners shares his insights in this podcast. Charlie discusses the impact that COVID-19 and the Oil ...

Podcast – Will Cullen, Vice President, LongPoint Minerals

Podcast – Will Cullen, Vice President, LongPoint Minerals

Will Cullen, Vice President, LongPoint Minerals shares his insights in this podcast. Will gives some insight on why many LPs still ...

Podcast – Marc Zimmermann, President & COO, Royalty Clearinghouse

Podcast – Marc Zimmermann, President & COO, Royalty Clearinghouse

Marc Zimmermann, President & COO, Royalty Clearinghouse shares his insights in this podcast. Over a 20 year history they have completed

Podcast – Darin Zanovich, President, Mesa Minerals Partners

Podcast – Darin Zanovich, President, Mesa Minerals Partners

Darin Zanovich of Mesa Minerals Partners shares his insights in this podcast. Darin talks about why this is an opportune time for long ...

Podcast – Ran Oliver, CEO, Viking Minerals

Podcast – Ran Oliver, CEO, Viking Minerals

In the first of our Mineral and Royalties series Viking Minerals, Ran Oliver describes the parallels between real estate and oil and ...

ENGAGING ENERGY
EXECUTIVES
GLOBALLY

Popular Links

  • How it works
  • Membership
  • Events
  • Thought Leadership
  • Podcasts
  • Contact Us

Connect

  • YouTube
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

Terms & Privacy
Energy Council © 2020. All Rights Reserved.

CLARION ENERGY LIMITED (Co.Reg.No 07098632) is registered in England and Wales, Registered Office: Bedford House, 69-79 Fulham High Street, London, SW63JW, United Kingdom. VAT No. GB 843845601

×

Thank you for your interest – please let us know if you are an Investor or an Oil & Gas Executive

I'm an Investor
I'm an Oil & Gas Executive
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.Ok